CarriersUTICA Group

GRAPHIC ARTS Mutual Insurance Company

NAIC company code25984
State of domicileNY
Lines writtenProperty & Casualty
GroupUTICA Group
Address180 GENESEE STREET, NEW HARTFORD NY 13413
Phone800-598-8422

New York auto complaint ranking

Ranked against other New York auto insurers by complaints per dollar of premium.3 years of data. Source: NY Department of Financial Services.

YearRankComplaintsUpheldPremium
20116300$1.6M
20104730$2.6M
20094800$3.2M

Connecticut complaints, 2020–2026

8 complaints filed with the Connecticut Insurance Department.

Claim Handling4
Underwriting2

Texas agency network

436 licensed Texas agencies are appointed to sell this company's products. An appointment is a formal authorisation filed with the state regulator.

Cities with the most appointed agencies:

Dallas22
San Antonio14
Austin14
Houston13
Grand Rapids6
Overland Park5
Fort Worth5
Tyler5
Plano5
Gainesville4

Source: Texas Department of Insurance active appointments. Texas only — this company may be appointed with many more agencies in other states.

Company data from the NAIC Detailed Listing of Companies, June 2026. Complaint data from state insurance regulators. Each state measures complaints differently, so figures are not comparable between states. This is not a rating or a recommendation.